Versions Compared

Key

  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.

-Scanned PDF

What is it to be rational?

...

Wiki Markup
Dennett goes on to argue, as it seems to me rightly, that "\[s\]cientific knowledge is the royal road \-\- the only road \-\- to evitability," i.e., to knowing "which interventions are apt to counteract which shortcomings" in an individual's making it over these two thresholds. His clear implication is that we have every reason to make any intervention that science shows to be indicated, asking rhetorically, "Why should it be important that you do all your self-improvement the old-fashioned way?" and calling us to acknowledge that "the environment we live in has been being updated ever since the dawn of civilization, elaborately prepared, made easy for us, with multiple signposts and alerts along the way, to ease the burdens on us imperfect decisionmakers" and humbly confessing that "\[w\]e lean on the prostheses that _we_ find valuable -- that's the beauty of civilized life \-\- even if we tend to begrudge those that others need.'"

...

All quotations are from Daniel C. Dennett, "On Failures of Freedom & the Fear of Science," Dædalus, 132, 1 (Winter 2002): 126-130.

6 March 2003