Versions Compared

Old Version 1

changes.mady.by.user Matthew Carroll

Saved on

compared with

New Version Current

changes.mady.by.user Andrew Scrimgeour

Saved on

Key

  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.

SCANNED PDF


Meaning-for-Us/Structure-in-Itself


According to Tillich, philosophy has to do with the structure of being in itself, while theology has to do with the meaning of being for us.


Assuming that Tillich's word "being" is his designation for what I should prefer should prefer to call "ultimate reality," I could accept this formulation, provided (1) one can one can take "philosophy" to mean, really, what Tillich himself calls "ontology" and I speak I speak of as "metaphysics"; and (2) one retains the distinction between theology and theology and faith, and hence the distinctive ways in which they both have to do with the meaning the meaning of being for us, theology's way bringing it into close contact with philosophy with philosophy as well as with metaphysics and morality. 


Assuming that these provisions, also, are met, I should want to stress that the that the meaning of being, or of ultimate reality, for us is intrinsically double-sided, in that in that it comprises both the ultimate reality that has a meaning for us and the us for us for which ultimate reality has a meaning, each understood in terms of the other. Thus  Thus ultimate reality is ultimate reality as authorizing our authentic selfunderstandingself-understanding, even as our authentic self-understanding ­understanding is our selfunderstanding self-understanding as authorized by ultimate reality.

As such, however, the meaning of ultimate reality for us involves both things both things to be believed (credenda) and  and things to be done (agenda) and therefore necessarily therefore necessarily has both metaphysical and moral implications. It necessarily has metaphysical has metaphysical implications in that, on the side of ultimate reality, the meaning of ultimate of ultimate reality for us necessarily presupposes the structure of ultimate reality in itselfin itself. It necessarily has moral implications in that, on the side of us, or our authentic our authentic self-understanding, the meaning of ultimate reality for us necessarily entails necessarily entails certain properly moral actions. 

7 January 1981; rev. 5 August 20022002