Presidents
- John McClintock, 1867-1870
- Randolph Sinks Foster, 1870-1873
- John Fletcher Hurst, 1873-1880
- Henry Anson Buttz, 1880-1912
- Ezra Squier Tipple, 1912-1929
- Arlo Ayres Brown, 1929-1948
- Fred Garrigus Holloway, 1948-1960
- Robert Fisher Oxnam, 1961-1974
- Paul Hardin III, 1975-1988
- Thomas H. Kean, 1990-2005
- Robert Weisbuch, 2005-
Acting Presidents
- John Pepin, 1960-1961
- John Pepin, 1974-1975
- W. Scott MacDonald, 1988-1990
Courtesy of the Drew University Archives